Who Has the Best Winter Coat? Gap Lands’ End LL Bean and Nautica Quality Coat Challenge

I was invited to take part in a Winter Coat Challenge. The brands were Lands’ End LL Bean, Nautica, and Gap. I have to admit that it was a very close race in my. I tried each coat and found something that I loved out of each of them. The first two were the closest as both Lands’ End and Nautica have different aspects that I like but at the end of the day I narrowed it down to one winner. It was Lands’ End

The Coats:

Gap

IMG_5690IMG_5691

Lands’ End

IMG_5698IMG_5700

Nautica

IMG_5686IMG_5685

LL Bean

IMG_5702IMG_5704

The Coat Fit: 

Nautica my only issue was that it wasn’t very fitted and the Zipper got caught the very first time I tried to zip it, It was such a challenge to get it unstuck I had to mention it here in the review. The Gap coat was just too boyish and too short for me, but if that’s your preference then it’s a very comfortable coat. I found the Land’s End coat to be my favorite. It’s fitted, long and very soft, the Nautica was a very close second while the LL Bean was weird. Plus my husband said the green from the LL Bean coat made me look like the Mrs Hulk The Incredible Hulk’s wife. In addition to the green the LL Bean coat was really odd with the belt.

Lands’ End won this round having little hooks I can use to make the coat even more fitted. I didn’t notice that feature at first glance so they are well placed.

The Pocket Comparison:

Pockets are pretty important to me. I’m always filling them with receipts and other things that the kids hand to me. Lands End had the most pockets with a secret inside lining pockets. They also had the best angles on the outside pockets. I really felt comfortable resting my hands in them. The LL Bean pockets were a good angle but a little small. Leaving my hands in them wasn’t exactly comfortable and I love to leave my hands in my pockets. Plus I wouldn’t be able to stuff them full of Kleenex and my hands. I found the Nautica pockets to be unique. At first I didn’t notice that they had a top opening and a side opening. I still found them to be a little square but like the difference in them. The difference meant storage and hand room. Nautica weakness in comparison to Lands’ End was no inner pockets. Gap had very comfortable pockets.

I feel this round was a tie between Lands’ End and Nautica because Nautica was so unique and Lands’ End were more comfortable.

The Warmth Challenge:

All the coats seemed to keep me warm, I think all the brands are great brands and as far as keeping me warm I would like anyone of them. The Gap coat was very warm but not long enough, I also felt it was too short in the arms, Nautica was very warm and comfy, LL Bean was warm and I liked the fit, Lands End was very warm, cozy and the sleeves were my favorite part. Oh and I also like the hood warmth and fit.

I like Lands End and Nautica about equal on this one. If I had to pick a winner it would be Lands’ End just because the fit made me feel more secure in the wind. With that extra button closure it gave me the feeling that I was covered more. I like how high up the button zipper closure is and the hood fit nicely. Also the sleeves hugging me closer in the Lands End coat felt nicer. The Gap coat just didn’t fit me well enough, and LL Bean did feel a little thinner in the wind. But I felt that the sleeves cuffs and the higher coverage around the neck were redeeming qualities in the LL Bean coat.

As fast as the hoods keeping my head warm, Gap had no hood. Lands’ End hood was my favorite because the inside of the hood was the softest. Nautica came in a very close second place as far as hood softness and warmth. LL Bean’s hood was rather thin. I love the fur edging but all the coats (except Gap with no hood) all of the hoods were removable.

LL Bean and Lands end were very close in this challenge. I think I prefer Lands End just because the hood, sleeves and fit were just a bit better than LL Bean.

.

The Price Line Up:

The Gap Coat Retails at $99.00

The Lands’ End coat retails at $179.50

The LL Bean coat retails at $179.00

The Nautica coat retails at $199.00

Now Even though the Gap Coat has the best price, it still depends on what you are looking for in a coat. Is the value in the coat worth the price you are going to pay. With all the features the Lands End coat has, it wins in the

Lands’ End was my favorite in quality, fit, softness. and detailing well worth the value.

The Quality Coat Review was a blind review.  In order to give my unbiased opinions, I am unaware of the company that sponsored the effort.  While the opinions are my own, I am being compensated through Mom Spark Media for my time. All of these coats are going to be donated to charity.

Recent Articles on Mom Start

Annie_poster-690x1024.jpg

Why You Should See Annie

Annie is the must see movie in this house. The kids can’t stop talking about it and I just have “Tomorrow” stuck in my head from dawn to dusk. So Why should you take your family to go see the movie this weekend starting on Friday December 19th? Annie (played by Quvenzhané Wallis)  is amazing […]

Holiday-Chocolate.jpg

20 Chocolate Recipes Perfect For the Holidays

  Peppermint Fluff Bundt Cake White Chocolate Covered Peppermint Rice Krispie Treats Make Peppermint Bark Chocolate Chip Orange Drops Mint Chocolate M & M Moon Pies Peanut Butter Toffee Chocolate Eclairs French chocolate tarte with dark chocolate ganache Christmas OREO Cookie Balls Christmas “Crack” Homemade Peanut Butter Cup Recipe! Peanut Butter Frosting The Chocolate Way! […]

Join the #RedThumb movement

Join The #RedThumb Movement: Don’t Text & Drive!

Gift card provided. Forget having a green thumb – having a red thumb is far more important. Why? Because the #RedThumb movement represents a pledge to not text and drive – ever. The idea was started by a man named Steve Babcock, who painted his thumbnails red as a reminder to himself to put down […]

Salba Chia Greek Yogurt

Salba Chia Greek Yogurt Recipe

‘Tis the season for sugar overload – so if you’re looking for a smart snack, Salba Chia have a simple yogurt recipe that will satisfy you for the same amount of calories you’d expend eating a cream puff: Salba Chia Greek Yogurt Recipe courtesy Salba Chia Ingredients: 1 cup plain non-fat Greek yogurt 1 TBSP. […]

Vintage Wreath Craft

Vintage Wreath Craft

Product provided. Over the past few months, I’ve been sharing seasonal crafts inspired by the QVC show You’re Home with Jill, hosted by Jill Bauer. If you need a little refresher on the show, here’s some quick info: QVC’s Jill Bauer hosts the network’s popular show, You’re Home with Jill® and provides fans with simple […]

Mrs. Claus

Santa & Mrs. Claus Want You to Have a Heart-Healthier Holiday!

This is a partnered post. Ho, ho ho! When we think of Jolly Old St. Nick, we usually think of leaving butter-filled cookies under the tree Christmas Eve and then nibbling on candy from our stockings all day long on Christmas! All of these things are wonderful – but Santa and his wife, Mrs. Claus, […]

Tuna Puffs

Tuna Puffs Recipe

Here’s another holiday appetizer from Starkist Tuna sure to get your mouth watering: Tuna Puffs Recipe courtesy Starkist Prep Time: 15 min; Cook Time: 20 min; Servings: 16 Ingredients: 2 pouches (2.6 oz) StarKist Tuna Creations®, Herb and Garlic 1 sheet frozen puff pastry, thawed 2 oz. goat cheese, crumbled ½ cup chopped fresh spinach […]

Roll & Surprise Animal Train by Vtech

Roll & Surprise Animal Train by Vtech

Sample provided. The Roll & Surprise Animal Train by Vtech is a great little toy that features: Pop-up animal surprises, over 55 songs, sounds and melodies, and interactive knobs and buttons. A classic toy that just gets better and better, with educational purpose as well as dexterity challenges to help those developing minds with a […]

gc

Grumpy Cat’s Worst Christmas Ever

Promotional DVD provided. This post contains our Amazon Associates link. Grumpy Cat’s Worst Christmas Ever starring everyone’s favorite feline, Grumpy Cat, is her debut Lifetime Movie. This movie is all you could ask for from a Lifetime Christmas flick. While it has subtle themes of “Home Alone,” Grumpy Cat’s Worst Christmas Ever is the tale […]

Hungry Girl - Tuna-Topped Wonton Crisps

Hungry Girl Tuna-Topped Wonton Crisps Recipe

Hungry Girl and Starkist Tuna are teaming up to share some holiday appetizer recipes with us – check this one out for your next gathering: Hungry Girl Tuna-Topped Wonton Crisps Recipe courtesy Starkist Prep Time: 10 min; Cook Time: 5 min Servings: 4 Ingredients: 12 small square wonton wrappers 2 pouches (2.6 oz.) StarKist Tuna […]

DIY-ornament-tutorials.jpg

The Best 40 Different DIY Ornament Crafts Perfect for your Christmas Tree

We love doing crafts at our house, it’s like Zoe’s favorite past time. So we thought it would be fun to share with you our finds across the internet. SO here are The Best 40 Different DIY Ornament Crafts perfect for your Christmas Tree. Simple Snowman Ornament How to Make Duck Tape Stars DIY Christmas […]

shutterstock_188775824-1.jpg

Important and Inspiring Quotes regarding Foster Care

With the movie Annie coming out we thought this informational piece would be fitting. Fostering a child is an incredibly rewarding journey, complete with highs, lows and everything in between. Some words of wisdom can really help make sense of some of the stages, or to even provide you with comfort, a smile or reiterate […]

gingerbeer (1)

Relax This Holiday Season With a Moscow Mule and Reed’s Ginger Beer

Samples provided for review Sometimes, you need to decompress from all the family time the holidays bring. I recommend a tropical escape with a refreshing and relaxing Moscow Mule, made from Reed’s Ginger Beer. Because my family is Polish, I decided to call this cocktail a Warsaw Mule instead of a Moscow Mule, and invited […]

LifeLock

Stay Safe While Holiday Shopping Online: 6 Tips

This is a partnered post. How is your holiday shopping coming so far? I have items picked out for a few people, but I still have quite a bit of looking to do – I haven’t wrapped one single present yet, so I guess I had better get on that. I think most people are […]

Give The Gift of Reading

Give The Gift of Reading #ReadMore

Disclosure: I am part of the PTPA Brand Ambassador Program with Kobo and I received Compensation as part of my affiliation with this group. The opinions on this blog are my own. When I was growing up, books were always a common gift under the tree. I read voraciously as a child and always wanted […]

blackquinoa (1)

Detox During the Holidays With Black Quinoa

Samples provided for review Everybody has a dark side. Fortunately, sometimes we’re able to explore that dark side with tasty snacks. When I heard about Royal Black Quinoa from Alter Eco, I jumped at the chance to try it. Fair trade, gluten free, protein-packed, and committed to sustainability? Yes please! After a lot of delicious […]

Classically Cozy

Style Hack: Stay Fashionably Warm This Winter! #YahooStyle

Thank you Yahoo! for sponsoring this post. While this was a sponsored opportunity from Yahoo!, all content and opinions expressed here are my own. Winter is almost here, and it sure feels like it. As someone who has always lived in colder climates, I’m OK with that – I get overheated extremely easily and I […]

I and love and you treats

I and love and you: Bob’s Verdict #furreal

Product provided. It’s been a month since I introduced you to I and love and you, a line of dog foods made with a high level of attention to quality and sustainability. I figured that Bob, Grandma’s Labrador, would probably like it OK. But I wasn’t expecting the reaction that I got! When I first […]

image.png

Get Guardians of The Galaxy Now and Watch The Bloopers!

We LOVED watching Guardians of the Galaxy and watched it as soon as it was delivered to our house. Now you can watch it at home too because it was released to DVD and Blu-ray yesterday December 9th. From Marvel, the studio that launched the epic franchises of “Iron Man,” “Thor,” “Captain America” and “Marvel’s […]

Comments

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *